Top Court Sets Aside Karnataka High Court Order, Citing Risk to Trial and Witness Influence
In a significant legal development, the Supreme Court of India has cancelled the bail of popular Kannada actor Darshan Thoogudeepa in connection with the brutal murder of a 33-year-old fan, Renukaswamy. The ruling comes as a major setback for the actor, who had earlier secured bail from the Karnataka High Court.
Supreme Court’s Strong Observations
A bench of Justices JB Pardiwala and R Mahadevan set aside the Karnataka High Court’s decision, stating that granting bail in this case could adversely impact the trial.
Key points from the court’s observations:
- The Karnataka High Court’s bail order reflected a “mechanical exercise of power.”
- Granting bail could lead to influencing witnesses.
- “However big the accused may be, he or she is not above the law,” said Justice Pardiwala, praising Justice Mahadevan for an “erudite judgment.”
Case Background
- Victim: Renukaswamy, aged 33, died due to “shock haemorrhage” caused by multiple blunt injuries, as per the autopsy report.
- Allegations: Darshan Thoogudeepa and some associates allegedly kidnapped, assaulted, and murdered the fan.
- Timeline:
- Darshan was arrested in the case and later granted bail by the Karnataka High Court in December last year.
- The State government appealed against the bail in the Supreme Court.
- The apex court has now cancelled the bail.
Victim’s Family Welcomes Verdict
Renukaswamy’s father expressed relief over the decision:
“When he got bail from the high court, we were stressed. Today, the Supreme Court has sent a strong message that no criminal can escape from the clutches of law.”
Legal Significance
The Supreme Court’s decision underscores:
- No individual, regardless of status, is above the law.
- Courts must carefully consider the impact of bail orders on witness safety and trial integrity.
The Supreme Court’s decision in the Darshan Thoogudeepa case sends a powerful reminder that justice stands above fame and influence, reaffirming that in India’s legal system, nobody is above the law.
Also Read : Supreme Court Slams High Court Over Bail for Actor Darshan in Renukaswamy Murder Case
